Rotate your device for best experience from site.

Agile story points estimation

by Simon Buehring
Discover how accurate story point estimation fuels team efficiency and project success, guiding you to more effective Agile delivery.
Agile story points estimation

Introducing Agile and story points

The Agile methodology stands out for its emphasis on iterative progress and constant adaptation. It’s a collection of practices and principles that prioritise delivering small, functional segments of software (or other products) frequently, providing value to customers at a steady pace. This approach contrasts with traditional waterfall methodologies, where the product is developed in a linear sequence, often leading to extended periods between releases.

Agile’s flexibility allows teams to incorporate feedback rapidly and pivot when necessary, ensuring that the end product is as close to the user’s needs as possible. This iterative cycle is facilitated by regular checkpoints where progress is reviewed, and direction can be adjusted – processes known as Sprints in Scrum, one of the most widely adopted Agile frameworks.

The utility of story points

Within Agile, story points represent a common tool for gauging the complexity of tasks rather than the time they may take to complete. Utilising an abstract unit to estimate effort, teams can sidestep the inaccuracies that can arise from individual work speeds and external interruptions. Story points provide a shared language for team members to discuss the demands of tasks, allowing for more effective prioritisation and planning.

By estimating tasks with story points, teams can better manage their Sprint capacity, ensuring realistic commitments and fostering a sustainable pace of development. This practice supports the Agile principles of sustainable development and team empowerment, allowing each member to contribute their expertise to the estimation process and collectively own the project roadmap.

Understanding story point estimation

Story point estimation is a cornerstone of Agile project management, helping teams measure the intensity of work involved in completing user stories – requirements or features from an end-user perspective. This metric is essential in planning Sprints and releases, allowing for a clear understanding of project scope from the outset.

What are story points?

Story points quantify the effort required to implement a user story. Unlike hours or days, which can be subjective and variable, story points assess the size, complexity, and risk associated with a piece of work. They offer a more holistic view, factoring in potential impediments and the effort to overcome them. By using points, Agile teams abstract away from time, focusing instead on relative difficulty across tasks.

The benefits of using story points

Employing story points in project management offers several advantages. They allow for more straightforward comparisons between tasks, facilitating prioritisation without getting bogged down in time-based predictions that are prone to inaccuracy. Points also promote consensus; teams discuss and agree on estimates, reinforcing a shared understanding of the project’s challenges. This collaborative process often unveils insights into potential issues before work begins, enhancing predictability and efficiency.

Setting up for estimation success

Before starting story point estimation, certain prerequisites and considerations must be met to set the stage for a successful estimation session. Proper preparation ensures that when the time comes to estimate, the team is aligned, informed, and ready to participate in a productive discussion.

Pre-estimation preparation

The foundation for successful story point estimation lies in thorough preparation. Teams must ensure that all members have a solid understanding of the project’s goals, the user stories at hand, and the estimation process itself. It’s crucial for the Product Owner to have refined the backlog and for any dependencies or impediments to be identified beforehand.

This level of preparation helps prevent the estimation process from stalling and ensures that every team member’s input is based on a comprehensive view of the work required.

Criteria for effective user stories

For user stories to be effectively estimated, they must be clear, concise, and testable. A good user story includes sufficient detail for the team to understand what needs to be done without prescribing how to do it. It should also contain acceptance criteria that define what ‘done’ looks like, as well as any non-functional requirements that may affect the story’s implementation.

Well-crafted user stories are the bedrock of effective story point estimation, enabling teams to assign points with confidence and clarity.

Key techniques for story point estimation

Accurate story point estimation can seem daunting, but several proven techniques can facilitate this process. Teams can choose from a variety of methods, each with its strengths, to determine which best fits their workflow and project needs. These techniques not only assist in obtaining estimates but also foster team collaboration and consensus.

The planning poker technique

Planning poker is a popular and interactive method for estimating story points that combines expert opinion, analogy, and consensus. Each team member is given a set of cards numbered to represent story points. For each user story, members privately select a card reflecting their estimate. Cards are then revealed simultaneously, prompting discussion when estimates differ significantly. The goal is to converge on a single estimate through consensus, drawing on the diverse perspectives within the team.

T-shirt sizing as an alternative

T-shirt sizing offers an intuitive approach to estimation, categorising tasks into sizes (XS, S, M, L, XL) instead of numerical values. This method simplifies the comparison between user stories, allowing teams to quickly group work into broad categories. The visual nature of T-shirt sizes aids in discussions about complexity and can be an excellent way to introduce new teams to the concept of relative estimation.

Using the Fibonacci sequence

The Fibonacci sequence is utilised in story point estimation to reflect the inherent uncertainty in larger, more complex tasks. As tasks increase in size, so does the difficulty in estimating them precisely. The Fibonacci sequence (1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, …) naturally creates a progressively divergent scale, encouraging teams to acknowledge and accommodate the uncertainty that comes with complex work. This method helps mitigate the risks of underestimation and provides a more realistic range for larger user stories.

Advanced insights into story estimation

Looking deeper into the nuances of story point estimation reveals its strategic impact on project success. It is not just a numerical exercise but a facet of project management that touches on team dynamics and future planning. Understanding these advanced aspects allows for a more nuanced approach to Agile project management.

Story estimation and team dynamics

The efficacy of story point estimation largely hinges on the composition and dynamics of the Agile team. Diverse experience and expert knowledge contribute to more accurate estimations, provided there is open communication and mutual respect.

When teams understand each other’s strengths and challenges, they can make more informed decisions about the effort required for tasks, leading to more accurate and reliable story points.

The role of velocity in estimation

Velocity measures the number of story points a team completes in a Sprint and is crucial in calibrating future estimates. By tracking velocity, teams gain insight into their capacity, helping them make more informed commitments for upcoming Sprints.

This metric is not about speed but about understanding a team’s consistent output, which in turn informs the story point estimation for future work with greater accuracy.

Common challenges and solutions

Story point estimation is not without its challenges. Agile teams often encounter various obstacles that can skew estimates and impact project timelines. However, recognising these common issues is the first step toward developing strategies to mitigate them and enhance the overall estimation process.

Overcoming estimation pitfalls

Some of the most common pitfalls in story point estimation include anchoring to past estimates, inflating points due to perceived complexity, and differing interpretations of what a point represents. To combat these, teams can ensure a shared understanding of point values, encourage fresh perspectives, and avoid comparing to past work. Regularly revisiting and recalibrating the estimation process also helps keep estimates accurate and relevant.

Improving estimation accuracy over time

As teams mature and gather more data from past Sprints, they can refine their estimation accuracy. Retrospectives play a significant role in this continuous improvement cycle, providing a forum to discuss what worked and what didn’t. Utilising historical data, such as velocity trends and estimation variances, informs better future estimates. The key is to treat estimation as a flexible and evolving process that improves as the team grows and learns together.

Integrating story points into Agile workflows

Incorporating story point estimation into Agile ways of working seamlessly connects planning with execution. It’s a critical step that ensures coherence between the estimated effort and the actual work carried out during the Sprints. This integration is fundamental for maintaining the rhythm and predictability of Agile project delivery.

From backlogs to Sprints

Once user stories are estimated with story points, they transition from the Product Backlog into planned Sprints based on the team’s velocity. This process ensures that each Sprint is filled with a feasible amount of work, helping to avoid overcommitment. Story points guide the Sprint Planning process, balancing the workload, and setting clear objectives for the team’s upcoming iteration.

Story points in progress tracking

Story points are not just for planning; they are pivotal for tracking progress as well. During Sprints, teams use story points to gauge whether they are on track to meet their goals. By comparing the completed points against the total points committed for the Sprint, teams can forecast end dates and make necessary adjustments.

This ongoing monitoring enables a proactive approach to project management, ensuring that delivery timelines remain realistic and achievable.


Agile story points estimation infographic

Learn from agile leaders

agileKRC has helped shape agile thinking by leading the teams that developed AgilePM® and PRINCE2 Agile®. We take a practical, success-oriented approach. We begin by taking the time to listen and understand your needs, before offering our real-world experience and expert guidance.

This website use cookies. Learn more